2 teaspoons lotion (any kind you like, if you have oily skin i would use one that is non-comedogenic so that there's no )
2 cotton balls
Put about 1 t. of lotion onto the lotion on the cotton ball and lightly rub it into the cotton. Gently, with eye closed, rub the cotton onto the eyelid and surrounding areas. Repeat this process with a Q-tip to help remove the makeup residue in hard to reach places.
Repeat with the other eye.
Follow up with your normal skin-cleansing and moisturizing routine.